All metrics in specified list

We tried using "where all metrics specified in list", so that we would only get alerts when two (or more) metrics are critical.  But it is alerting when only one metric is true; tried disabling "when severity has changed" and that only made it worse by alerting every refresh (every 5 minutes)  And yes, we restarted services in between each change.

I've searched the community and haven't found anyone else (yet) experiencing this...We're on version, so is this a known bug or what am I missing?